Dinner
APPETIZERS
Cocktail Shrimp
Chilled jumbo shrimp with Sarah's zesty cocktail sauce
Fried Shrimp
Beer battered jumbo shrimp, in house tartar sauce.
Quiche
Three cheese blend, sautéed spinach.
Crab Cakes
Maryland crab cakes, remoulade sauce.
Wingettes
Buffalo, Jerk, or Honey BBQ
SOUPS & SALADS
Matza Ball Soup
Traditional
Chicken Noodle Soup
Soothing
Citrus Salad
Freshly picked greens, mandarin oranges, blueberries, grape tomatoes, craisins, goat-cheese-crumble, tossed with Sarah's house dressing.
+ $0 Grilled Chicken
House Salad
Mesclun mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, tossed with Sarah's house dressing. Substitute Dressings - Italian, Ranch, or Blue Cheese.
+ $0 Grilled Chicken
$0 Grilled Shrimp
All meals include cornbread.
POULTRY
Chicken Grapes & Wine
Sautéed chicken cutlet, table grapes, white wine sauce, steamed asparagus.
Baked Chicken
Apricot glazed chicken, garlic butter haricots verts.
Curried Chicken
Curried chicken, served with pigeon peas and rice.
Fried Chicken
Served with mashed potatoes
FISH
Salmon
Oven broiled fillet with garlic & oil, sautéed spinach.
Lobster
Broiled lobster tail, steamed broccoli.
Fried Whiting
Pan-fried, sautéed Okra.
BEEF
Filet Mignon
6 Oz pan-seared fillet, red wine sauce, new potatoes, sautéed spinach.
+ $0 Bacon
Sarah's Burger
Ground Turkey or 8 Oz Angus Beef with our secret spices, topped with cheddar cheese, caramelized onions, sautéed mushrooms, lettuce, tomato, pickle, truffle fries.
+ $0 Bacon
$0 Sweet Potato Fries
Oak Bluffs Brisket
Drenched in thin gravy, served on a bed of rice & collard greens.
VEGETARIAN CORNER
Panko Crusted Eggplant
Marinara sauce
Pasta Primavera
Vegetable Tempura
Sweet & Sour
There is no meat or pork in any of our side dishes.
SIDES
Mac & Cheese
Three cheese blend
Governor Scott's Potato Salad
Alice Yams
Rice Pilaf
Black Eye Peas
Aunt Mott's Lima Beans
Garlic Butter Haricots Verts
Sarah's Signature String Beans
Collard Greens
Sautéed Okra
Brussel Sprouts
Steamed Broccoli
CHILDREN MEALS
Chicken Fingers
With Broccoli
Sliders
With French Fries
Grilled Cheese
DESSERT
Peach Cobbler
Banana Pudding
Key Lime Cake
Red Velvet Cake
PORCH PARTY
Inkwell Chicken
Fried Chicken in a gable box (10, 15, or 20 pieces). Great for porch parties or Beach outings.
Feeds family of Four, all meals include cornbread.
FAMILY-TIME MEALS
Meal #1
Chicken (fried, bbq, or baked), Macaroni & Cheese, Sarah's Signature String Beans.
Meal #2
BBQ Ribs St. Louis, Seared Vegetables, Corn on the cob.
Meal #3
Fried Whiting, Collard Greens, Potato Salad.
Meal #4
Baked Salmon, Rice Pilaf, Sarah's Signature String Beans.